How to Streamline Vendor Selection

Selecting a vendor involves more than just picking a product. CISOs today realize the process should include several factors beyond simply purchasing products. Vendor selection is about building strategic partnerships that support organizational goals, regulatory compliance, and cybersecurity resilience.

With increasing responsibilities and growing scrutiny from regulators, CISOs must select vendors that match their ultimate goals and deliver on expectations during proof of concepts (PoCs). A PoC typically is a demonstration of a security solution’s effectiveness in performing specific tasks or protecting against specific threats. Essentially, a PoC is a small-scale project or experiment that validates the feasibility of the security solution before a company commits to a full-scale implementation. When working with vendors on a PoC, CISOs must be clear and precise with their expectations. And vendors must fully understand the request for information (RFI) or request for proposal (RFP) responses, distinguishing between critical requirements and nice-to-have features. Before any PoC or demonstration of the product, CISOs must detail how the solution will be deployed within their environment so the vendors can tailor the demo to operational realities.

Here we share some key practices CISOs can adopt to drive more effective PoCs and long-term vendor relationships. A structured approach can benefit CISOs when evaluating and collaborating with vendors.

What to Ask When Evaluating Security Vendors

Clear and precise requirements are critical to a successful PoC. CISOs must set the proper expectations for vendors during this process.

When defining requirements, CISOs should:

• Ask for documentation, ensuring the vendors understand your detailed RFI-RFP requirements.
• Clarify priorities, distinguishing between must-have, nice-to-have, and optional features to avoid wasted effort.
• Provide use-case context, helping vendors better understand exactly how their solution will be used in your environment.

CISOs should approach PoCs considering realistic timelines, the complexity of the solution, as well as the internal team’s bandwidth.

• Set clear timelines based on your team’s availability, technical complexity, and decision-making windows.
• Request setup effort estimates to better understand how much internal resourcing the PoC might require.
• Require a software bill of materials (SBOM) that demonstrates vendor transparency.

 When selecting a product, it’s critical to secure vendor-provided support and training that must follow product implementation. Expectations for post-sale support should be set early, and CISOs can measure the vendor responsiveness to their needs during the PoC. CISOs should ask vendors:

• Will your team offer onboarding or training for our staff?
• What materials such as manuals, tutorials, or live sessions, will be available to your team?
• How will you team engage with vendor support, for instance, via ticketing, chat, or direct escalation?
  

Training and support are critical indicators of long-term success so be sure to fully understand how onboarding happens and how support will be handled following the vendor’s product implementation.

Download: Prep for a Continued Uptick in Third-Party Risks in 2025

Key Questions During the Vendor PoC Process

Security should be a foundational component in any third party business.

It is critical to understand vendors’ security practices, privacy controls, and data protections. It’s important CISOs get information on vendors’ encryption protocols, access controls, authentication methods, third-party certifications, and compliance with frameworks such as GDPR, CCPA, or HIPAA.

Read: AI and Third Parties: How to Hold Vendors Accountable

Key questions for potential vendors in relation to their security products:

• Can you explain how the product handles encryption, access controls, authentication, and third-party certifications?
• How does the product handle and store sensitive data in relation to risk?
• Is it compliant with GDPR, CCPA, or HIPAA?
• What do you offer in terms of vulnerability management, threat intelligence feeds, and incident response playbooks?
• Can you provide logs, audit trails, and compliance documentation?
• Can the solution scale with our environment?
• Can you provide architectural diagrams, API documentation, and references showing integration with tools already in use?
• Do you have case studies or customer references you could provide that align with our vertical industry and company size?
• What is your business continuity plan?
• How do you handle disaster recovery?
• Are you trying to be acquired?
• How can we avoid vendor lock-in?

Download: Incident Response Plan Template

Tips to Improve Vendor Collaboration

Set the tone early with prospective vendors: you’ll expect transparency, timely responses, and collaborative problem-solving as part of the potential relationship. Open communications from both parties will foster honest dialogue, rapid response times, and more flexibility when challenges do arise.

CISOs and security teams should first communicate clearly with their own internal stakeholders before signing with a vendor. Relay the desired outcomes of the vendor partnership and share timelines with stakeholders. Ask your colleagues to share feedback and assess how well your vendors response to constructive criticism. Also be sure to use metrics to track project progress and evaluate your vendor’s performance.

By taking ownership of the process and asking thoughtful, proactive questions, CISOs can avoid wasted effort and improve confidence in solution selection. Efficient vendor selection lays the groundwork for a stronger, more effective security foundation and maximizes ROI for the business.

How to Maximize Vendor Cybersecurity Impact with IANS

You're facing budget pressures to do more with less, we're here to help. See real results on how IANS clients (and your peers) save time, decrease costs and reduce risk. Go to our resource page to Maximize Cybersecurity Impact with IANS and you’ll find client success stories that enabled:

• 25% decrease of insurance premiums through risk reduction
• $150k in savings through optimized headcount
• Avoidance of a 75% loss in annual revenue

Although reasonable efforts will be made to ensure the completeness and accuracy of the information contained in our blog posts, no liability can be accepted by IANS or our Faculty members for the results of any actions taken by individuals or firms in connection with such information, opinions, or advice.