In today’s enterprise environments, insider threats remain one of the most persistent—and most complex—risks to mitigate. Unlike external attacks that come from the outside, insider threats come from people with legitimate access: employees, contractors, or partners who, intentionally or not, compromise systems or data.

Creating an insider threat program isn't simply about layering on more security tools. It requires a fundamental shift in how organizations think about trust, privacy, liability, and accountability. Unlike traditional security programs that focus on defense and detection, insider threat programs operate at the intersection of HR, legal, risk, and InfoSec—and must be guided as much by governance and process as by technology.

Mishandling Insider Threats Breaks Trust

Insider threat programs can fail not because a threat is missed, but because the organization mishandles how it responds. If InfoSec drives the investigation without proper legal oversight, it can lead to morale issues, accusations of discrimination, or even civil lawsuits.

That’s why the most successful programs are HR-led, legally guided, and backed by executive sponsorship, usually from the Chief Risk Officer (CRO). Cybersecurity may uncover the signals, but HR must validate and direct investigations with input from legal. Without this structure, even well-meaning efforts can do more harm than good.

READ MORE: How to Apply the Three Lines of Defense

Building the Insider Threat Team

An effective program includes a cross-functional team:

• Cybersecurity selects and deploys monitoring tools (such as user and entity behavior analytics) and reports alerts.
• HR leads investigations and makes determinations in coordination with legal and business units.
• Legal counsel defines acceptable investigative boundaries to minimize liability.
• IT supports deployment of tools and assists with forensic data access.
• Physical security, if needed, assists with asset retrieval or access monitoring.
• Business unit leaders provide context for flagged activity.
• Union representatives, where applicable, ensure contractual compliance.

The program must also enforce strict confidentiality—NDAs for participants are essential to prevent internal leaks that can undermine investigations and organizational trust.

Don’t Treat Insiders Like Hackers

One of the most damaging mistakes organizations make is approaching insider threat investigations like external threat hunts. Unlike malware or network intrusions, insider threats involve people—and mishandling investigations can result in reputational and legal consequences.

Monitoring or targeting a specific employee without proper justification and process can backfire. The answer isn’t “monitor everyone all the time”—it’s establishing clear governance: define who initiates investigations, who approves them, and what controls are allowed at each step.

DOWNLOAD OUR GUIDE: Threat Intelligence Policy and Procedure

Build the Threat Program on Process, Not Just Tools

There is no single product that solves for insider threats. It takes layers of control across identity, data, behavior, and physical access. According to IANS’ Insider Threat Program Checklist, here’s what a mature program should include:

Policy and Governance

• Clear insider threat policies and onboarding NDAs
• Regular insider risk assessments
• Defined ownership of the insider threat function

Access Controls

• Role-based access and least privilege enforcement
• Privileged access management (PAM) with just-in-time provisioning
• Regular access reviews and identity lifecycle management

Monitoring and Detection

• UEBA for behavioral analytics
• Data Loss Prevention (DLP) for file and email activity
• Real-time alerts for suspicious actions
• Endpoint and network monitoring
• Screen, keystroke, and clipboard tracking in high-risk areas

Security Awareness

• Insider threat modules in employee training
• Anonymous reporting channels to surface concerns

Incident Response

• Predefined workflows for investigating insider incidents
• Guidance from Legal and HR throughout the investigation
• Drills and simulations to validate plans

Offboarding and Physical Security

• Immediate deactivation of access upon termination
• Secure return of assets and data
• Visitor management and facility access controls

Third-Party Risk and Continuous Improvement

• Background checks and contract clauses for vendors
• Metrics and KPIs to track improvements over time
• Post-incident reviews to identify gaps

READ MORE: How to Reduce Third-Party Security Risks

Threat Investigations Require Coordination—and Caution

A typical insider threat investigation doesn’t start with a smoking gun—it starts with a behavioral anomaly. A UEBA alert flags a user accessing large volumes of sensitive files at odd hours. InfoSec reviews the data and confirms it's not a false positive. Then the alert is handed to HR, who works with business unit leaders to validate whether an investigation is warranted.

From that point forward, HR—not InfoSec—directs the steps, with legal’s guidance. If physical assets need to be retrieved, the physical security team is brought in. Cybersecurity provides technical findings, but any investigative action—searches, interviews, terminations—flows through HR. In union environments, representatives may also need to be looped in according to contractual obligations.

Insider Threat Programs Are a Long Game

Managing insider risk is not a one-and-done exercise. It requires sustained investment in governance, tooling, and collaboration. It also demands humility—the recognition that technology alone can’t detect intent, and that heavy-handed approaches can breed more risk than they reduce.

By grounding insider threat programs in legal discipline, HR leadership, and shared responsibility, organizations can walk the fine line between vigilance and overreach. With the right structure, insider threat programs don’t just protect the enterprise—they build a culture of accountability and trust.

Download our Security Budget 2025 Benchmark Summary Report—and gain access to valuable insights and guidance to overcome budget obstacles.

Take our CISO Comp and Budget Survey in less than 10 minutes and receive career-defining data and other valuable insights and data sets.

Security staff professionals can take our 2025 Cybersecurity Staff Compensation and Career Benchmark Survey.

Although reasonable efforts will be made to ensure the completeness and accuracy of the information contained in our blog posts, no liability can be accepted by IANS or our Faculty members for the results of any actions taken by individuals or firms in connection with such information, opinions, or advice.